When to Replace vs Repair Your AC Unit: A Peninsula Homeowner's Guide

The 50% Rule

A common rule of thumb: if a repair costs more than 50% of a new system, replacement often makes more sense. But that's not the whole picture for Peninsula homeowners.

Age Matters

AC systems typically last 10-15 years in our mild Peninsula climate. If your unit is:

• Under 8 years: Repair usually makes sense
• 8-12 years: Consider repair costs carefully
• Over 12 years: Start thinking about replacement

Peninsula-Specific Factors

Our coastal climate is relatively mild compared to inland areas. This means:

• Your AC may last longer than average
• Efficiency gains from new units may be less dramatic
• Heat pump hybrids are worth considering

Signs It's Time to Replace

• Frequent repairs - More than 2-3 per year
• R-22 refrigerant - This is phased out and expensive
• Rising energy bills - Older units lose efficiency
• Uneven cooling - Hot spots that won't go away
• Strange noises - Grinding, squealing, or banging

When Repair Makes Sense

• Single component failure - Capacitor, contactor, etc.
• Minor refrigerant recharge - If no leak present
• Thermostat issues - Often inexpensive to fix
• Duct problems - Separate from the AC unit itself

Get a Professional Opinion

We're happy to assess your system and give you an honest recommendation. No pressure - we'll explain your options and help you make the right choice for your home and budget.